Business Buyout Valuation in California: Fair Value vs. Fair Market Value

Once both sides accept that an owner is leaving, the dispute usually narrows to valuation — and valuation is where a great deal of money is won or lost. Two owners can look at the same company and arrive at numbers that differ by multiples, depending on the standard applied, the valuation date, and the assumptions baked into the appraisal. Stone LLP has litigated and negotiated these buyout values for Southern California owners for more than 45 years.

Fair value vs. fair market value — why the words matter

Corporations — “fair value” (§ 2000)

In a corporate buyout to avoid dissolution, the shares are purchased at their fair value, determined under section 2000. If the parties don’t agree, the court appoints three disinterested appraisers to set fair value as of the valuation date.

LLCs — “fair market value” (§ 17707.03)

In an LLC buyout, the moving member’s interest is purchased at fair market value — a standard that looks to what the interest would fetch in the market and that can account for market conditions differently than corporate “fair value.”

The levers that move a buyout number

Valuation date — the company’s value can look very different depending on the date the court or statute fixes.
Discounts — whether minority and marketability discounts apply, and how, can swing value substantially.
Normalizing the financials — adding back excessive insider compensation, perks, and related-party charges.
Goodwill and intangible value — often the largest and most contested component.
The appraisers — who is appointed, what they’re instructed to value, and how their work is challenged.

The appraisal process

When the owners can’t agree on value, the statutes route the question to court-supervised appraisal. The court typically appoints disinterested appraisers, the proceeding may be stayed while they work, and the resulting valuation is subject to confirmation and challenge. Shaping the appraisal — the instructions, the standard, the date, the inputs — is where experienced advocacy earns its keep, because the appraisers’ number often becomes the price.

Whether you’re buying or selling

The selling owner wants the highest defensible value; the buying owner wants a disciplined, well-supported number that keeps the company affordable to retain. We represent owners on both sides and work alongside qualified valuation experts to build, attack, and defend buyout numbers. For more than 45 years, Stone LLP has helped Southern California owners protect what their interest is really worth — from Orange County and Los Angeles to San Diego and the Inland Empire.

Call 949-477-9100

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between fair value and fair market value in a buyout?

For corporate shares under section 2000, the standard is fair value, a defined statutory measure. For LLC interests under section 17707.03, the standard is fair market value, which looks to a hypothetical market sale. The applicable standard depends on the entity type and can change the result.

How is a business valued in a forced buyout?

If the owners can’t agree, the court appoints disinterested appraisers to value the interest as of a valuation date. Key drivers include the valuation date, applicable discounts, normalized financials, and the treatment of goodwill.

Can minority and marketability discounts reduce my buyout?

They can, depending on the standard and the facts. Whether discounts apply, and how large they are, is frequently one of the most heavily contested issues in a buyout valuation.

Can I challenge the appraisers’ valuation?

The appraisal is subject to the statutory process, including court confirmation, and the inputs and instructions can be contested. Experienced advocacy in shaping and challenging the appraisal can significantly affect the final number.