California Right To Repair Act Construction Defects and SB 800 | Stone LLP

When it comes to construction defects in California, the Right to Repair Act (SB 800) plays a major role. Found in California Civil Code Section 895 et seq., SB 800 sets clear standards that homeowners, and developers must follow to ensure defect-free construction. SB 800  outlines a specific process that both homeowners and developers must follow to address construction defects before filing a lawsuit, making it a critical part of California construction defect law.

In this, we’ll explore what constitutes a construction defect under the Right to Repair Act and the types of legal claims homeowners can pursue. Whether you’re a homeowner, builder, or developer, understanding this law is essential for protecting your rights and mitigating risk.

Construction defects california - Elloite stone

What Is a Construction Defect?

Under California’s Right to Repair Act,, a construction defect refers to a flaw in the design, materials, or workmanship of a home (house, condominium or townhouse) that results in a failure to meet applicable building standards or causes damage to the property. Construction defects may be immediately noticeable or may remain hidden (latent) for years before becoming apparent.

Four primary categories of construction defects:

  1. Design Defects: Defects in architectural plans or defective engineering designs.
  2. Material Defects: Use of substandard or defective building materials (e.g., defective windows or defective roof).
  3. Workmanship Defects: Poor craftsmanship or failure to follow design specifications.
  4. Subsurface Defects: Issues with soil, grading, or drainage that compromise the structure’s foundation (e.g., grading defects).

Construction defects can lead to secondary issues such as water intrusion, mold, cracking walls, or roof failures. Under California’s Right to Repair Act, homeowners have several legal options to seek repairs, compensation, or other remedies when construction defects are discovered.

OUR CONSTRUCTIONS CAN HELP YOU TODAY

Legal Framework for Construction Defects in California

California’s legal framework for construction defects includes both common law and statutory law. Homeowners can bring claims under various legal theories, including:

1. Breach of Contract

When a builder or contractor fails to deliver a home or project in accordance with the terms and quality standards specified in a written agreement, the property owner can sue for breach of contract. This is common in cases where express warranties or guarantees were provided.

Negligence involves the failure of a contractor or design professional to perform their duties with reasonable care which results in damage to the property, or a person, as a result of the failure to use reasonable care. Homeowners may claim that the builder’s conduct fell below the industry standard and that this caused the defects and resulting damage.

3. Breach of Warranty

Express Warranty: A written or verbal promise about the quality or longevity of work. Implied Warranty: Even without a written agreement, California law assumes construction will be done in a “workmanlike manner.”

4. Strict Residential Liability

In residential construction, builders can be held strictly liable for construction defects—even if they weren’t negligent or didn’t breach a contract.

5. Statutory Violations

Violations of building codes, consumer protection, or environmental laws statutes may also form the basis for legal action.

Understanding Civil Code 895 – The California Right to Repair Act

California Civil Code Section 895 et seq.—also known as SB 800—was enacted in 2002 and applies to all new residential construction sold after January 1, 2003. Its goal is to establish minimum building performance standards and a pre-litigation resolution process to avoid costly litigation.

Key Features of SB 800:

  • Applies to new residential construction only.
  • Establishes detailed building quality standards.
  • Requires homeowners to follow a specific pre-litigation process.
  • Allows builders the opportunity to inspect and repair (or offer the homeowner money) before litigation.

Let’s break these components down.

Building Performance Standards Civil Code 896

SB 800 outlines specific standards that cover nearly every aspect of a residential structure, found at California Civil Code section 896, including:

  • Water intrusion prevention (e.g., roof, windows, stucco, and flashing)
  • Structural integrity (e.g., foundations, framing, load-bearing walls)
  • Mechanical systems (e.g., HVAC, electrical, plumbing)
  • Exterior elements (e.g., balconies, decks, siding)
  • Soil and grading performance

These standards are designed to ensure that construction meets not just local building codes, but also functional expectations like longevity, safety, and maintenance predictability.

SB 800 Pre-Litigation Process

One of the most important aspects of SB 800 is its pre-litigation process, which must be followed before a homeowner can file a lawsuit (except in cases where damage has already occurred to other parts of the property).

The Process Includes:

  1. Notice of Claim: The homeowner must provide the builder with written notice identifying the alleged defect(s) with enough detail to allow investigation.
  2. Acknowledgment & Inspection: The builder has 14 days to acknowledge the claim and another 14 days to schedule an inspection.
  3. Testing: Builders may conduct testing and even open up walls or structures to assess the damage.
  4. Repair Offer: Within 30 days of inspection, the builder can offer to repair the defect and compensate for related damages. The builder must also include a timeline for repairs.
  5. Homeowner Response: The homeowner has 30 days to accept or decline the offer. If declined, a reason must be stated for the refusal.
  6. Repair Timeline: If accepted, repairs must begin within 14 days and be completed with “utmost diligence.”
  7. Failure to Comply: If the builder fails at any point—by not responding, offering repair, or completing repairs—the homeowner may proceed with a lawsuit.

Exceptions to SB 800 Procedures

There are a few notable exceptions to the SB 800 requirements:

  • If the defect has already caused damage to other parts of the home, the homeowner can bypass SB 800 and go straight to court.
  • Builders may opt out of the SB 800 process, but only if they explicitly state so in the purchase agreement.

SB 800 Statute of Limitations

A statute of limitations is a law that limits the time in which one must bring their claims. Generally speaking, claims under SB800 must be brought within 10 years from the date the home is first sold when new.

Remedies Available Under the Right to Repair Act

Once a defect claim is validated through the Right to Repair Act —the homeowner may be entitled to:

  • Repairs by the builder or the  reasonable cost of those repairs
  • Replacement or reimbursement for damage to the properties
  • Costs for temporary relocation or storage
  • Loss of business income (if applicable)
  • Attorney’s fees and expert witness costs (in some cases)

The law aims to restore the property to a condition it should have been in had it been properly constructed.

Gain an Unfair Advantage – Choose an Experienced Legal Team

Navigating the complexities of California’s construction laws, particularly the Right to Repair Act (SB800), requires seasoned legal expertise. At Stone LLP, we specialize in representing contractors, apartment owners, luxury homeowners, real estate investors, commercial and industrial building owners, and government entities in construction defect disputes. Our deep understanding of construction law and the nuances of SB800 positions us to effectively handle cases involving substandard construction, design defects, resultant damages, insurance coverage disputes, and construction contract disagreements.

With offices across California, including Irvine and Los Angeles, our attorneys are well-versed in the state’s legal landscape. We are committed to delivering results, whether through negotiation, mediation, or litigation, ensuring that our clients’ interests are vigorously protected.

Trust the experienced team at Stone LLP to provide the legal support.

The Importance of Construction Defect Attorneys

Given the complexity of construction defect claims and the specific procedural requirements under the Right to Repair Act, it’s essential to work with an experienced California construction defect attorney. These cases often require expert testimony, detailed inspections, and careful legal analysis.

At Stone LLP, our experienced team of attorneys is well-versed in the nuances of SB 800 and the Right to Repair Act and broader California construction law. Whether you’re facing water damage, structural issues, or mechanical failures in your home, we can help you navigate the legal process and pursue a full and fair recovery.  

Practical Tips for Homeowners

  • Document Everything: Take photos and maintain a log of defects, repairs, and communications.
  • Act Quickly: Don’t delay in sending notice to the builder once a defect is discovered.
  • Review Your Purchase Agreement: Understand any clauses related to arbitration, mediation, or Right to Repair Act (SB 800) opt-outs.
  • Consult an Attorney Early: Even before contacting the builder, a lawyer can ensure your rights are protected.

     

California’s construction defect laws—and specifically the Right to Repair Act—provide powerful protections for homeowners but require precise compliance with procedural rules. The pre-litigation process is designed to reduce conflict, save money, and encourage timely repairs, but it only works if both parties understand and follow the steps required.

Whether you’re a homeowner dealing with water intrusion, a cracked foundation, or failing stucco, or a builder trying to manage risk and stay in compliance, the Right to Repair Act is a cornerstone of California construction law that can’t be ignored.

If you believe your home may have construction defects or have questions about your rights under California’s Right to Repair Act (SB 800), don’t wait. Contact our experienced California construction defect lawyers today for a no cost case evaluation.

WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAYS

Contact Us

 
 

ASSOCIATIONS AND MEMBERSHIPS